Due to the good news from Germany, there may be slightly longer delivery times!

Added value through secondary optics?

The cultivation of plants produces resin and pollen during the flowering phase, which settles on surfaces over time. In addition, chemicals such as sulfur are used in fertilizer or pest control in plant cultivation. While pollen reduces the light output of LED due to contamination, sulfur attacks the internal reflectors of mid power LED.

Especially Mid Power LED have to be protected from these influences to achieve the specified lifetime. In the following article we would like to show you the different technical possibilities to protect the heart of every LED luminaire.

Unprotected LED

LED without any protection are directly exposed to environmental influences such as moisture and chemicals. These factors cause the LED to age rapidly. The actual service life of the LED is stated to be significantly longer, but an unprotected LED can lose more than 10% of its light output within one year. Since the soft silicone of the LED is virtually impossible to clean, this light loss is irreversible. Furthermore, sulfur and other chemicals diffuse through the silicone encapsulation of the LED. Once sulfur reaches the core of the LED, it destroys the LED’s internal reflector (see figure at left). As a result, the light output is significantly reduced.

Advantages:

  • Maximum light output of the new LED
  • No light loss due to covers/protection
  • Maximum reduction in manufacturing costs

Disadvantages:

  • Losses due to stray light
  • Losses due to pollution
  • Losses due to corrosion of the internal reflectors
  • No protection of electrical contacts against water and moisture
  • Shortened service life, or loss of light after a few hours of operation

Protection through coating - "Coating"

Some manufacturers protect their LED with silicone or polyurethane coatings. This should protect the LED and its contacts sufficiently against splash water and humidity. However, these coatings are difficult to clean, just like the LED. The same applies to the diffusion of sulfur through the silicone coating. This leads to LED aging at approximately the same rate as with unprotected LED. Due to the low layer thickness, little light is lost through the coating itself.

Advantages:

  • Maximum light output of the new LED
  • Little light loss due to covers/protection
  • Reduction of manufacturing costs
  • Protection of electrical contacts against water and moisture

Disadvantages

  • Losses due to stray light
  • Losses due to pollution
  • Losses due to corrosion of the LED internal reflectors
  • Shortened service life, or loss of light after a few hours of operation

Protection through two-dimensional cover

Often, a flat, translucent cover is placed over the LED to protect it. The cover can be screwed, clipped or glued. Materials such as PMMA, PC or glass are used here. Depending on the material used, the losses due to transmission and total reflection vary. Coated glass has the best performance with approx. 1% light loss, but is heavy and very cost-intensive. Polycarbonate causes up to 12% light loss from the LED to the light emission point. In addition, the material yellows and also reduces the output power in the medium term. Acrylic glass (PMMA) is characterized by less light loss (approx. 8%) and significantly better long-term stability. In summary, flat two-dimensional covers incur losses due to transmission and total reflection. Therefore, the efficiency in the data sheet of such luminaires is usually worse than that of unprotected LEDs. Nevertheless, a longer lifetime can be assumed than for unprotected or coated LEDs.

Provided that the covers used actually seal the LED, they offer sufficient protection against moisture and chemicals. However, the combination of aluminum heat sink and glass or plastic covers should be viewed critically. Especially with longer (>500mm) linear luminaires (light bars), there are often problems with the tightness of the encapsulation due to the different linear expansions of the material combinations.

Advantages of two-dimensional covers:

  • Good protection of electrical contacts against water and moisture
  • Depending on the material, the cover is good to clean
  • No or little loss of light due to soiling (cleaning of the cover possible)
  • Depending on the material, there are low manufacturing costs

Disadvantages of two-dimensional covers:

  • Losses due to stray light
  • Losses due to total reflection
  • Light losses due to transmissio

Protection through three-dimensional secondary optics

All current SANlight models are equipped with a secondary optic made of PMMA. In the EVO-Series, for example, this optic is bonded to the heat sink and the LED is thus completely encapsulated and optimally protected from external influences. The selected high tech material causes lowest transmission losses. Losses caused by total reflection are reduced to an absolute minimum by the three-dimensional design of the light entry surface. Overall, the SANlight secondary optics cause only 4% light losses. Given the sophisticated design of the optics, stray light from the LED is captured and directed to the plants. In addition, the light control distributes the light efficiently and homogeneously over the cultivation area. In general, the generated light losses caused by the optics are completely compensated by the capture of stray light as well as the perfect light control.

In practice, this means that although our data sheet does not give the best efficiency values, more light actually reaches the plants than with apparently (according to the data sheet) more efficient luminaires. The light output remains constant over years and given the possibility to clean the optics, the specified lifetime (LM90) is achieved.

Advantages SANlight secondary optics

  • Best protection of electrical contacts against water and moisture
  • Best protection of LED from chemicals, water and moisture
  • Light loss due to transmission and total reflection is fully compensated by light control
  • No or little loss of light due to contamination (cleaning of optics possible)
  • Minimized losses due to stray light
  • Homogeneous light distribution

Disadvantages

  • Higher manufacturing costs

SANlight Blog

Show all